Pirates is learning when not to invent.

The source reconstruction stays behind a parity gate until the original game is accounted for. Expansion waits for evidence.

Evidence reviewed 2026-09-28
Filed under
Field note
Source state
Editor-reviewed public summary

A generative system can produce a plausible answer to an unknown. Plausibility is not a recovered rule.

A plausible rule can still be invented.

Master of the Secret Sea is being reconstructed from original source evidence. The project is not yet free to treat an interesting idea as part of the original game.

That constraint matters because agentic systems can make missing details look finished. A familiar genre convention may be plausible, coherent and wrong for this specific source.

Keep uncertainty visible

Archaeology, specification, parity implementation and expansion are separate phases. Gate B remains locked until the reconstruction has enough source-backed coverage to support a claim of parity.

The factory recovers code and records what is known, what is missing and what agents may not invent.

Decision

No procedural fork is approved while the original game’s parity gate remains locked.

Original game evidence informs reconstruction; the reconstructed game must reach integrated parity before Gate B can open. Unresolved source details stay unknown rather than being invented.
Parity before expansionGate B stays locked until integrated parity is supported by the original game’s evidence.View the system model (D2)
Read the diagram in text

Original game evidence — keep source claims tied to what is available.

Reconstruction — rebuild the original game’s behavior before adding new systems.

Integrated parity — compare the reconstructed game against its source.

Gate B — expansion stays locked while parity remains unresolved.

Record boundary

Some source repositories are private. This publication does not reproduce raw issue text or private conversation transcripts.

Source and review

Shareable factory snapshot reviewed 28 September 2026; no private repository or conversation material is reproduced. The publication does not reproduce private repository bodies or conversation transcripts.

Back to the stories

What changed

An explicit locked gate makes uncertainty visible and keeps creativity out of the wrong phase.

Proof boundary

Reviewed 2026-09-28. This is an edited public record, not a private source transcript.